Accept: 7
Reject: 13
Batting average: 0.35
Temperature Dependence of CO2 Densimetry Using Micro-Raman Spectrometry
投稿日：2016/03/07，判定通知日：2016/03/17，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem lett，査読人数：3
Your manuscript has been reviewed with the aid of three independent referees. Although two of the referees found this manuscript interesting and useful, the remaining reviewer recommended that it would be rejected for publication in Chemistry Letters in its present form. Since the comment of Reviewer 2 is so serious, the authors are kindly advised to conider and revise the manuscript in a major way. Thus this manuscript has been decided to be rejected.
Temperature Dependence of CO2 Densimetry Using Micro-Raman Spectrometry
投稿日：2016/03/28，判定通知日：2016/04/06，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem lett，査読人数：5
Your manuscript has been reviewed with the aid of five independent referees, since their evaluation and recommendation of this manuscript varied.
Although two of the referees found this manuscript interesting and useful, they recommended that it would require some revision. In particular one of them suggested practically major revision including important and many issues. The remaining three declared that this mansucirpt should be rejected for publication in Chemistry Letters. Considering all the reviewers' comments, this manuscript has been rejected.
Temperature Dependence of CO2 Densimetry Using Micro-Raman Spectrometry at Laboratory Condition
投稿日：2016/06/24，判定通知日：2016/07/11，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem lett，査読人数：3
Although two of the referees found this manuscript interesting and useful, the remaining one recommended that it would be rejected for publication in Chemistry Letters becuase of the reasons below. Although only one referee gave us negative comments, the points raised by him/her are worthy of deliberate consideration. Considering all the comments, the data presented here have something useful and important for particular researchers, but not for general readers of Chemistry Letters. Not to mention of urgency, novelty and broad interest leading to a new chemistry, which are key factors for Chemistry Letters.
Temperature Dependence of CO2 Densimetry Using Micro-Raman Spectrometry at Laboratory Condition
投稿日：2017/04/09，判定通知日：2017/04/11，判定：Reject，雑誌：GJ，査読人数：0
We have finished initial evaluation on the manuscript. I acknowledge that the manuscript contains important technical details on Raman spectroscopy for determining CO2 density in fluid illusions in minerals. I agree that the effect of temperature to Raman spectra are one of the important issue for precise spectral measurements. However, it is very difficult to find impact in geochemistry which convince urgency and novelty for Express Letters in Geochemical Journal
Temperature Dependence of CO2 Densimetry Using Micro-Raman Spectrometry at Laboratory Condition
投稿日：2017/07/24，判定通知日：2017/08/31，判定：Major revision，雑誌：GJ，査読人数：2
Reviewers have now commented on your paper. Both of the reviewers acknowledge the merit of this manuscript. However, as mentioned by the second reviewer, more experiments are required to justify the work. English should be improved after the major modification. I expect it will take a bit long time to complete the revision. If you are prepared to undertake the work required, I would be pleased to reevaluate the paper.
Temperature Dependence of CO2 Densimetry Using Micro-Raman Spectrometry at Laboratory Condition
投稿日：2017/10/25，判定通知日：2018/01/26，判定：Accept，雑誌：GJ，査読人数：2
I am pleased to tell you that your work has now been accepted for publication in Geochemical Journal. It was accepted on 2018-01-26 19:42:54
CO2 Raman Thermometer Improvement: Comparing Hot Band and Stokes and Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Thermometers
投稿日：2017/12/04，判定通知日：2017/12/11，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem lett，査読人数：2
Your manuscript has been reviewed with the aid of two independent referees. Although the referees found this manuscript interesting, one of them recommended that it would be rejected for publication in Chemistry Letters in its present form. The remaining reviewer has pointed out that the manuscript fails to address the originality and novelty of the work. Accordingly, both reviewers evaluated both "Urgency" and "Novelty" lower than those Chemistry Letters requires for publication whether the manuscript needs due revision or not. Thus it has been decided that this manuscript should be rejected at this stage.
CO2 Raman Thermometer Improvement: Comparing Hot Band and Stokes and Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Thermometers
投稿日：2018/01/04，判定通知日：2018/01/24，判定：Minor revision，雑誌：Chem lett，査読人数：3
The evaluations of this Ms by the reviewers are different from each other, but most of them have recommended publication, and also have suggested some minor revisions to your manuscript. Therefore, I invite you to respond to the reviewers' comments and revise your manuscript.
CO2 Raman Thermometer Improvement: Comparing Hot Band and Stokes and Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Thermometers
投稿日：2018/01/26，判定通知日：2018/01/30，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem lett，査読人数：3
Your manuscript has been reviewed with the aid of three independent referees. Although one of the referees found this manuscript interesting and useful,
the other two reviewers recommended that it would be rejected for publication in Chemistry Letters due to the following reasons.
CO2 Raman Thermometer Improvement: Comparing Hot Band and Stokes and Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Thermometers
投稿日：2018/02/08，判定通知日：2018/03/24，判定：Major revision，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
Your manuscript has been reviewed with the aid of three independent referees. Although one of the referees found this manuscript interesting and useful,
the other two reviewers recommended that it would be rejected for publication in Chemistry Letters due to the following reasons.
CO2 Raman Thermometer Improvement: Comparing Hot Band and Stokes and Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Thermometers
投稿日：2018/03/28，判定通知日：2018/06/06，判定：Minor revision，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
It is a pleasure to accept your manuscript in its current form for publication in Journal of Raman Spectroscopy.
CO2 Raman Thermometer Improvement: Comparing Hot Band and Stokes and Anti-Stokes Raman Scattering Thermometers
投稿日：2018/07/05，判定通知日：2018/07/12，判定：Accept，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
It is a pleasure to accept your manuscript in its current form for publication in Journal of Raman Spectroscopy.
Temperature dependence of Raman CO2 densimetry: real-time densimetry development to clarify fluid inclusion re-equilibration processes
投稿日：2018/03/30，判定通知日：2018/05/27，判定：Reject，雑誌：Am mineral，査読人数：3
On the basis of the reviewers' comments, as well as my own evaluation, I regret to inform you that we will not be able to publish your paper American Mineralogist.
Thermoelastic equilibrium of fluid inclusion-host mineral systems under homogenization measurement
投稿日：2018/11/12，判定通知日：2019/01/19，判定：Major revision，雑誌：JMPS，査読人数：2
Reviewers have now commented "Potentially acceptable after major change" on your manuscript. You will see that they are advising that you revise your manuscript.
Thermoelastic equilibrium of fluid inclusion-host mineral systems under homogenization measurement
投稿日：2019/01/28，判定通知日：2019/02/07，判定：Major revision，雑誌：JMPS，査読人数：2
Reviewers have now commented "Potentially acceptable after major change" on your manuscript. You will see that they are advising that you revise your manuscript.
Thermoelastic equilibrium of fluid inclusion-host mineral systems under homogenization measurement
投稿日：2019/02/12，判定通知日：2019/04/26，判定：Minor revision，雑誌：JMPS，査読人数：2
Reviewers have now commented as "acceptable after minor change" on your manuscript. You will see that they are advising that you revise your manuscript.
Residual pressure measurement and detection of small H2O amounts in high-pressure H2O-CO2 fluid inclusions using Raman frequency shifts and bandwidths of CO2
投稿日：2019/02/24，判定通知日：2019/02/26，判定：Reject，雑誌：GCA，査読人数：0
After initial evaluation the Editorial Board has concluded that this paper is better suited for consideration by another journal, and is therefore being returned to you without external review. Please see below for additional comments. I would therefore like to suggest that you consider taking advantage of an article transfer service that allows your article to be considered by another, possibly more appropriate journal. This gives you the option of having your manuscript files and details transferred automatically to that journal without having to resubmit and reformat the manuscript.
Residual pressure measurement and detection of small H2O amounts in high-pressure H2O-CO2 fluid inclusions using Raman frequency shifts and bandwidths of CO2
投稿日：2019/02/27，判定通知日：2019/07/31，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem Geol，査読人数：3
Thermoelastic equilibrium of fluid inclusion-host mineral systems under homogenization measurement
投稿日：2019/05/17，判定通知日：2019/06/06，判定：Accept，雑誌：JMPS，査読人数：2
The associate editor has reported that your revised manuscript has been modified adequately in response to the reviewers' comments and he could assure this to be published in Journal of Mineralogical and Petrological Science (JMPS).
Temperature-dependence of a Raman CO2 densimeter
投稿日：2019/07/11，判定通知日：2020/11/25，判定：Reject，雑誌：Chem Geol，査読人数： 1
I very much regret to inform you that publication in our journal is not recommended by Professor Donald Dingwell, the Editor-in-Chief. An explanation for this decision is given in the attached review reports (and on https://ees.elsevier.com/chemge/). I hope that the comments contained therein will be of use to you.
Residual pressure measurement and detection of small H2O amounts in high-pressure H2O-CO2 fluid inclusions using Raman frequency shifts and bandwidths of CO2
投稿日：2019/10/22，判定通知日：2020/12/3，判定：Major Revision，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
Pressure measurement and detection of small H2O amounts in high-pressure H2O–CO2 fluid up to 141 MPa using Fermi diad splits and bandwidths of CO2
投稿日：2020/1/18，判定通知日：2020/02/21，判定：Accept，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
Experimental variable effects on laser heating of inclusions during Raman spectroscopic analysis
投稿日：2020/6/18，判定通知日：2020/06/19，判定：Reject，雑誌：GCA，査読人数：0
Thank you for your submission to Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. After initial evaluation the Editorial Board has concluded that this paper is better suited for consideration by another journal, and is therefore being returned to you without external review. Please see below for additional comments.
I would therefore like to suggest that you consider taking advantage of an article transfer service that allows your article to be considered by another, possibly more appropriate journal. This gives you the option of having your manuscript files and details transferred automatically to that journal without having to resubmit and reformat the manuscript.
Experimental variable effects on laser heating of inclusions during Raman spectroscopic analysis
投稿日：2020/6/19，判定通知日： 2020/09/1，判定： Major Revision，雑誌：Chem Geol，査読人数：2
I can now inform you that the reviewers and editor have evaluated the manuscript "Experimental variable effects on laser heating of inclusions during Raman spectroscopic analysis" (Mr. Yuuki Hagiwara). Please submit your revised manuscript within 21 days from the date of decision.
Experimental variable effects on laser heating of inclusions during Raman spectroscopic analysis
投稿日：2020/9/15，判定通知日： 2020/10/14，判定： Accept，雑誌：Chem Geol，査読人数：1?
I am pleased to inform you that the manuscript "Experimental variable effects on laser heating of inclusions during Raman spectroscopic analysis" (Mr. Yuuki Hagiwara) has now been accepted for publication.
Temperature dependence of a Raman CO2 densimeter from 23 to 200°C and 7.2 to 248.7 MPa: Evaluation of density underestimation by laser heating
投稿日：2021/01/29，判定通知日：2021/03/23，判定：Major Revision，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
Temperature dependence of a Raman CO2 densimeter from 23 to 200°C and 7.2 to 248.7 MPa: Evaluation of density underestimation by laser heating
投稿日：2021/03/30，判定通知日：2021/06/7，判定：Accept，雑誌：Jour Raman Spectros，査読人数：2
Equation of state of spinel (MgAl2O4): Constraints on self-consistent thermodynamic parameters and implications for elastic geobarometry of peridotites and chromitites
投稿日：2022/05/23，判定通知日：2022/10/5，判定：Minor revision，雑誌：Contrib. Min. Petrol.，査読人数：2
Post-entrapment over-pressurization of fluid inclusions by elastic deformation: Implications for fluid inclusion geobarometry of peridotites and phenocrysts
投稿日：2022/07/13，判定通知日：2022/10/13，判定：Reject，雑誌：Am. Min，査読人数：1
Equation of state of spinel (MgAl2O4): Constraints on self-consistent thermodynamic parameters and implications for elastic geobarometry of peridotites and chromitites
投稿日：2022/10/21，判定通知日：2022/11/3，判定：Accept，雑誌：Contrib. Min. Petrol.，査読人数：2
Post-entrapment density modification of fluid inclusions by elastic deformation: Implications for fluid inclusion geobarometry of peridotites and phenocrysts
投稿日：2022/12/14，判定通知日：2023/3/10，判定：Reject，雑誌：Am. Min，査読人数：0